Lowest sugar items at Andy’s Frozen Custard you must try. In this post, I am going to be sharing the lowest sugar items at Andy’s Frozen Custard. In it, I will share a selection of lower-sugar frozen custards, Italian Ices, and drinks you can order from Andy’s Frozen Custard. Serving since 1986 Andy’s Frozen Custard may be a local institution where you are from, but what exactly are the lowest sugar options available on the menu? .
What Are The Lowest Sugar Items At Andy’s Frozen Custard
As a general rule, the best way of ordering a lower-sugar frozen custard at Andy’s Frozen Custard is to order a kid’s or small vanilla or chocolate frozen custard topped with nuts, pretzels, or espresso. The Italian ices and custard bars are also lower sugar options. Diet Coke and unsweetened iced tea are sugar-free.
Summary Table – Lowest Sugar Orders at Andy’s Frozen Custard
Below is a summary table of the lowest sugar orders available from Andy’s Frozen Custard together with the sugar content per serving.
The items picked range from 0g-24g of sugar. Whilst 24g of sugar may not be considered as ‘low’ by everyone, it is worth bearing in mind that a large triple chocolate concrete at Andy’s Frozen Custard contains 130g of Sugar. So, if you are watching your sugar content a 24g sugar order rather than a 130g sugar order is a win.
| 10 Lowest Sugar Orders At Andy’s Frozen Custard | Sugar Content |
|---|---|
| Unsweetened Tea | 0g |
| Diet Coke | 0g |
| Nut, Pretzel & Espresso Toppings | 0g-1g |
| Andy’s Vanilla Kids Custom Sundae | 21g |
| Lemon Italian Ice | 23g |
| Raspberry Lemon Italian Ice | 23g |
| Small Vanilla Cone/Cup | 23g |
| Small Chocolate Cone/Cup | 24g |
| Dark Chocolate Custard Bar Coffee | 24g |
| Dark Chocolate Custard Bar Coffee | 24g |
10 Lowest Sugar Order At Andy’s Frozen Custard
In this section, I will go through my picks for the 10 lowest sugar items at Andy’s Frozen Custard.
1. Unsweetened Iced Tea – 0g of Sugar
If you find yourself in an Andy’s Frozen Custard and want a zero-sugar option, then I have news to break to you. There are no sugar-free frozen desserts at Andy’s frozen custard. If you are willing to settle for a drink, then unsweetened tea is sugar-free.
2. Diet Coke – 0g of Sugar
The other zero-sugar option on the menu at Andy’s Frozen Custard is Diet Coke.
3. Nut, Pretzel & Espresso Toppings 0g-1g of Sugar
In terms of toppings, the following toppings are the lowest sugar toppings at Andy’s Frozen Custard. They all contain 1g of sugar per serving apart from the espresso which is sugar-free.
- Espresso – 0g of Sugar
- Almonds – 1g of Sugar
- Crushed nuts – 1g of Sugar
- Peanuts – 1g of Sugar
- Pretzels – 1g of Sugar
- Roasted pecans – 1g of Sugar
4. Andy’s Vanilla Kids Custom Sundae – 21g of Sugar
Andy’s Vanilla Kids Custom Sundae is the lowest-sugar frozen dessert on the menu. One of these contains 21g of sugar before any toppings are added. So long as you are just adding nuts or pretzels, that shouldn’t increase the sugar content too much.
5. Lemon Italian Ice – 23g of Sugar
If you love tart Italian ice then it’s great to know that the Italian ices at Andy’s Frozen Custard are one of the lower-sugar frozen desserts on their menu. Refreshing, fruit, tart, and 23g of sugar per serving. What more could you want?
6. Raspberry Lemon Italian Ice – 23g of Sugar
The raspberry lemon Italian ice also contains 23g of sugar. That raspberry and lemon combo really is unbeatable.
7. Small Vanilla Cone/Cup – 23g of Sugar
A small cup or come of Andy’s Vanilla custard will contain 23g of sugar. My personal recommendation for toppings? Roasted pecans and espresso – resulting in pecan coffee pie vibes. The sugar content of this sundae combo would be 24g of sugar.
8. Small Chocolate Cone/Cup – 24g of Sugar
A small cup or cone of Andy’s frozen custard contains 24g of sugar. I also love the fact that a cone doesn’t add to the sugar content. My personal recommendation for toppings? Crushed nuts and pretzels – clocking in at 26g of sugar.
9. Dark Chocolate Custard Bar Coffee – 24g of Sugar
If you are looking for a lower-sugar to-go item at Andy’s Frozen Yogurt, then definitely try the dark chocolate custard coffee bar yum.
10. Dark Chocolate Custard Bar Mint – 24g of Sugar
If mint is more your flavor over coffee, then also try the dark chocolate custard mint bar which also contains 24g of sugar.
10 Lowest Sugar Items at Andy’s Frozen Custard You Must Try
Lowest sugar items at Andy’s Frozen Custard you must try. What have we learned from the above? Well, when it comes to sugar there are no sugar-free options at Andy’s Frozen Custard. However, this is no surprise given that it is a dessert chain. If you are looking for a lower sugar option, your best bet is to pick a kid’s size custom sundae (which comes out at 21g of sugar) and add either nuts or pretzels as a topping (which will add an additional 1g to 2g of sugar).
If you are looking for something more refreshing then some Italian Ices come in at 23g of sugar. If you want something sugar-free, I am afraid it would have to be Diet Coke or Unsweetened iced Tea.
Just remember Andy’s Frozen Custard is a dessert chain so if you want to limit your sugar content always opt for ordering the smallest size available on the menu. The smaller the serving size the lower the sugar.
And Remember…
Ingredients and/or manufacturing processes may change. Always double-check ingredient lists and nutritional information before purchasing any food items.
WANT TO FIND MORE LOW SUGAR OPTIONS?
Do you want to learn about some other low-sugar options at your favorite coffee chains, fast food, or restaurant joints, or just while you are shopping for groceries? If you do, then check out some of my other articles below:
