- As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. I am compensated for referring traffic to Amazon.
The best sugar free store-bought cake frostings. In this post, I am going to be sharing with you the 9 best sugar free store-bought cake frostings available. I have already covered low-sugar cake mixes (20 of the Best No Added Sugar Cake Mixes), brownie mixes (14 Best Sugar Free Brownie Mixes), and cookie mixes (13 best sugar free cookie mixes) in previous posts, but I am yet to cover the most important part of any baked item…the frosting. Let’s face it, a cake is not a cake without frosting. It just isn’t. However, if you are looking to watch your sugar intake then frosting is not your best friend. Typically made from butter and sugar (a lot of sugar) – frostings are generally not low in sugar. So, what exactly are some of the best sugar-free cake frostings available?
What Are The Best Sugar-Free Cake Frostings Available?
As a general rule the following brands make sugar free frostings:
- Good Dee’s
- Pillsbury
- Keto and Co
- Keystone
- Duncan Hines
- GramZero
These frostings are chocolate or vanilla flavored and contain 0g of sugar per serving.
9 of The Best Sugar Free Store-Bought Cake Frostings – Item By Item
In this section, I will go through each of my 9 picks for the best sugar free store-bought cake frostings.
1. Good Dee’s Vanilla Frosting
This sugar free vanilla frosting from Good Dee’s is sweetened with allulose and contains 0g of sugar per serving. It is also vegan, Atkins-friendly, keto-friendly, and gluten-free.
You can find it on Amazon here.
I have already talked about Good Dee’s before in several posts I have written:
- 12 Best Sugar Free Waffle and Pancake Mixes
- 14 Best Sugar Free Brownie Mixes
- 14 of the Best Sugar Free Muffin Mixes
- 20 of the Best No Added Sugar Cake Mixes
- 13 Best Sugar Free Cookie Mixes
2. Good Dee’s No Milk Chocolate Frosting
Good Dee’s sugar free frosting also comes in a chocolate variety (known as ‘no milk chocolate’ as it is also vegan). You can find it on Amazon here.
3. Pillsbury Creamy Supreme Sugar Free Chocolate Fudge Frosting
I have talked about Pillsbury sugar free frosting before in the post I wrote on the best sugar free cake mixes (20 of the Best No Added Sugar Cake Mixes). This frosting is sweetened with sucralose, maltitol syrup, isomalt, and sorbitol. This variety is chocolate fudge! Yum.
You can try it on Amazon here.
4. Pillsbury Creamy Supreme Sugar Free Vanilla Flavored Frosting
Pillsbury’s sugar free frosting also comes in a vanilla variety – perfect for all you sugar-conscious vanilla lovers out there.
Find it on Amazon here.
5. Buttercream Keto Frosting Mix by Keto and Co
If a keto buttercream style frosting is what you are looking for then look no further than this frosting from Keto and Co.
You can check this buttercream keto frosting out on Amazon here.
Not only is it sugar-free but it is also keto (the name kind of gave that away), only contains 0.5g of net carbs, and is gluten-free. This frosting is sweetened with Wondrose sugar replacer (erythritol, non GMO soluble corn fiber, inulin, monk fruit, and natural flavors).
6. Keystone Pantry Sugar-Free Butter Cream Vanilla Frosting Mix
Next up – another vanilla sugar free frosting. This time from Keystone Pantry. This frosting is sweetened with allulose, contains 0g net carbs per serving, and is gluten-free.
You can treat yourself to this frosting from Amazon here.
It is also worth mentioning that the dairy used in Keystone’s frostings is kosher as well.
7. Keystone Pantry Sugar-Free Butter Cream Chocolate Frosting Mix
Keystone also has a chocolate version of their sugar free frosting, which you can find on Amazon here. Just add water and voila!
8. Duncan Hines Keto Friendly Vanilla Flavored Frosting
This “sweet and creamy” keto frosting from Duncan Hines is sweetened with erythritol, inulin, monk fruit, and allulose. So “skip the added sugar, not the sweets” (Duncan Hine’s words not mine). You can get this frosting from Amazon here.
9. GramZero Vanilla Whip Mix
The final entry on this list comes from GramSugar. This vanilla frosting is sugar free and is instead sweetened with polydextrose, maltodextrin, and Stevia. This frosting is also low-calorie.
You can find it on Amazon here. It is also interestingly promoted as a mousse on its Amazon listing.
Summary Table – Sugar Free Store-Brought Cake Frostings
Below is a summary table of my picks for the 9 best sugar free store-bought cake frostings. I also list the sweetener used in each frosting and the amount of sugar per serving. All the frostings on the below list contain 0g of sugar per serving.
| Sugar Free Store-Bought Cake Frosting | Sweeteners Used | Sugar Content Per Serving |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Good Dee’s Vanilla Frosting | Allulose | 0g |
| 2. Good Dee’s No Milk Chocolate Frosting | Allulose | 0g |
| 3. Pillsbury Creamy Supreme Sugar Free Chocolate Fudge Frosting | Sucralose, maltitol syrup, isomalt and sorbitol | 0g |
| 4. Pillsbury Creamy Supreme Sugar Free Vanilla Flavored Frosting | Sucralose, maltitol syrup, isomalt and sorbitol | 0g |
| 5. Buttercream Keto Frosting Mix by Keto and Co | Wondrose sugar replacer (erythritol, non GMO soluble corn fiber, inulin, monk fruit, and natural flavors) | 0g |
| 6. Keystone Pantry Sugar-Free Butter Cream Vanilla Frosting Mix | Allulose | 0g |
| 7. Keystone Pantry Sugar-Free Butter Cream Chocolate Frosting Mix | Allulose | 0g |
| 8. Duncan Hines Keto Friendly Vanilla Flavored Frosting | Erythritol, inulin, monk fruit, and allulose | 0g |
| 9. GramZero Vanilla Whip Mix | Polydextrose, maltodextrin, and Stevia | 0g |
Sugar Free Frostings F&Q
How Much Sugar Is In Sugar Free Frosting?
As a general rule, sugar free frosting contains 0g of sugar per serving.
Does Duncan Hines Make Sugar Free Frosting?
Duncan Hines does make a sugar free frosting – Duncan Hines Keto Friendly Vanilla Frosting. This frosting is sweetened with erythritol, inulin, monk fruit, and allulose and contains 0g of sugar per serving.
What Sweetener Is Used In Pillsbury Sugar Free Frosting?
Pillsbury sugar free frosting is sweetened with Splenda (sucralose), as well as maltitol syrup, isomalt, and sorbitol.
Does Sugar Free Frosting Exist?
Sugar free frosting does exist. Sugar free frostings do not contain sugar and are instead sweetened with erythritol, inulin, monk fruit, allulose, isomalt, sorbitol, polydextrose, maltodextrin, allulose, and/or Stevia.
Who Makes Sugar Free Frosting?
The following brands make sugar free frostings:
- Good Dee’s
- Pillsbury
- Keto and Co
- Keystone
- Duncan Hines
- GramZero
9 of The Best Sugar Free Store-Bought Cake Frostings – The Final Bite
The best sugar free store-bought cake frostings. What have we learned from the above? Well, when it comes to cake you can still have the frosting if you are watching your sugar intake. That is because there are plenty of sugar free frosting options available to buy from grocery stores and online. Now you just must find some sugar-free cake to put it on top of. Luckily, I have also put together a list of the 20 Best No Added Sugar Cake Mixes you can pair your sugar free frosting with. Or you could just eat the frosting. I’ll leave that up to you.
And Remember…
Ingredients and/or manufacturing processes may change. Always double-check ingredient lists and nutritional information before purchasing any food items.
WANT TO FIND MORE LOW SUGAR OPTIONS?
Do you want to learn about some other low-sugar options at your favorite coffee chains, fast food, or restaurant joints, or just while you are shopping for groceries? If you do, then check out some of my other articles below: